| History:
(1) A fee, gratuity, or other consideration may not be paid for a claimant in connection with any proceedings arising under this chapter, unless approved as reasonable by the judge of compensation claims or court having jurisdiction over such proceedings. Any attorney's fee approved by a judge of compensation claims for benefits secured on behalf of a claimant must equal to 20 percent of the first $5,000 of the amount of the benefits secured, 15 percent of the next $5,000 of the amount of the benefits secured, 10 percent of the remaining amount of the benefits secured to be provided during the first 10 years after the date the claim is filed, and 5 percent of the benefits secured after 10 years. The judge of compensation claims shall not approve a compensation order, a joint stipulation for lump-sum settlement, a stipulation or agreement between a claimant and his or her attorney, or any other agreement related to benefits under this chapter that provides for an attorney's fee in excess of the amount permitted by this section. The judge of compensation claims is not required to approve any retainer agreement between the claimant and his or her attorney. The retainer agreement as to fees and costs may not be for compensation in excess of the amount allowed under this section.
(2) In awarding a claimant's attorney's fee, the judge of compensation claims shall consider only those benefits secured by the attorney. An attorney is not entitled to attorney's fees for representation in any issue that was ripe, due, and owing and that reasonably could have been addressed, but was not addressed, during the pendency of other issues for the same injury. The amount, statutory basis, and type of benefits obtained through legal representation shall be listed on all attorney's fees awarded by the judge of compensation claims. For purposes of this section, the term "benefits secured" does not include future medical benefits to be provided on any date more than 5 years after the date the claim is filed. In the event an offer to settle an issue pending before a judge of compensation claims, including attorney's fees as provided for in this section, is communicated in writing to the claimant or the claimant's attorney at least 30 days prior to the trial date on such issue, for purposes of calculating the amount of attorney's fees to be taxed against the employer or carrier, the term "benefits secured" shall be deemed to include only that amount awarded to the claimant above the amount specified in the offer to settle. If multiple issues are pending before the judge of compensation claims, said offer of settlement shall address each issue pending and shall state explicitly whether or not the offer on each issue is severable. The written offer shall also unequivocally state whether or not it includes medical witness fees and expenses and all other costs associated with the claim.
(3) If any party should prevail in any proceedings before a judge of compensation claims or court, there shall be taxed against the nonprevailing party the reasonable costs of such proceedings, not to include attorney's fees. A claimant shall be responsible for the payment of her or his own attorney's fees, except that a claimant shall be entitled to recover a reasonable attorney's fee from a carrier or employer:
(a) Against whom she or he successfully asserts a petition for medical benefits only, if the claimant has not filed or is not entitled to file at such time a claim for disability, permanent impairment, wage-loss, or death benefits, arising out of the same accident;
(b) In any case in which the employer or carrier files a response to petition denying benefits with the Office of the Judges of Compensation Claims and the injured person has employed an attorney in the successful prosecution of the petition;
(c) In a proceeding in which a carrier or employer denies that an accident occurred for which compensation benefits are payable, and the claimant prevails on the issue of compensability; or
(d) In cases where the claimant successfully prevails in proceedings filed under s. 440.24 or s. 440.28.
Regardless of the date benefits were initially requested, attorney's fees shall not attach under this subsection until 30 days after the date the carrier or employer, if self-insured, receives the petition.
(4) In such cases in which the claimant is responsible for the payment of her or his own attorney's fees, such fees are a lien upon compensation payable to the claimant, notwithstanding s. 440.22.
(5) If any proceedings are had for review of any claim, award, or compensation order before any court, the court may award the injured employee or dependent an attorney's fee to be paid by the employer or carrier, in its discretion, which shall be paid as the court may direct.
(6) A judge of compensation claims may not enter an order approving the contents of a retainer agreement that permits the escrowing of any portion of the employee's compensation until benefits have been secured.
(7) If an attorney's fee is owed under paragraph (3)(a), the judge of compensation claims may approve an alternative attorney's fee not to exceed $1,500 only once per accident, based on a maximum hourly rate of $150 per hour, if the judge of compensation claims expressly finds that the attorney's fee amount provided for in subsection (1), based on benefits secured, fails to fairly compensate the attorney for disputed medical-only claims as provided in paragraph (3)(a) and the circumstances of the particular case warrant such action.
History.--s. 34, ch. 17481, 1935; CGL 1936 Supp. 5966(34), 8135(11); s. 11, ch. 20672, 1941; ss. 17, 35, ch. 69-106; s. 365, ch. 71-136; s. 119, ch. 71-355; s. 18, ch. 75-209; s. 9, ch. 77-290; ss. 10, 23, ch. 78-300; ss. 27, 124, ch. 79-40; ss. 15, 21, ch. 79-312; s. 14, ch. 80-236; s. 12, ch. 83-305; s. 4, ch. 86-171; ss. 19, 43, ch. 89-289; ss. 29, 56, ch. 90-201; ss. 27, 52, ch. 91-1; s. 32, ch. 91-46; s. 3, ch. 91-47; s. 252, ch. 91-224; s. 34, ch. 93-415; s. 120, ch. 97-103; s. 21, ch. 2001-91; s. 13, ch. 2002-236; s. 26, ch. 2003-412.
|
Relevant Case Law
Note: Deputy Commisioner did not abuse his broad discretion by reducing the award; interest continues to accrue on attorneys fees from the date opf teh award even if Deputy Comiisioneer retains jurisdiction onteh issue.
Note: Award of attorneys fee not improper when carrier fails in its affirmative duty to reasonably investigate within 21-day notice period.
Note: Fee award unjustified where injury admitted and dispute as to benefit period only.
Note: There is no basis for an attorney's fee in Section 440.34, Florida Statutes (Supp.1978), for when a client disappears and is due compensation, a fee is only proper when a claim has been successfully prosecuted and an award of compensation has been made.
Note: When, in the usual course of business of a corporation, an officer or other agent is held out by the corporation or has been permitted to act for it or manage its affairs in such a way as to justify third persons who deal with him in inferring or assuming that he is doing an act or making a contract within the scope of his authority, the corporation is bound thereby.
Note: Where rehabilitation is involved, the date of maximum medical improvement is artifically established by statute after the rehabilitation program has been completed.
Note: Award of attorney's fees may be excessive where case presents no novel or unusual issues.
Note: Award of attorney's fee pursuant to Section 440.34 (2) (c) improper unless a carrier or employer denies denies a compensable injury occurred.
Note: A claimant's testimony may be considered, but cannot replace the treating physician's expert opinion as to when temporary disability ends and permanent disability begins; award of attorney's fees proper where carrier or employer denies a compensable injury occurred.
Note: Emp[loyer has 21 days in which to investigate claim and burden to act when sufficient information is obtained; when a scheduled injury produces a disability or incapacity in a non-scheduled portion of the body, the claimant should be rated for the body as a whole rather than the legislative prescription for scheduled injuries.
Note: When a claimant prevails on the issue of unpaid doctor bills, and the doctor's testimony was relevant thereto, a witness fee should be awarded as costs.
Note: A claimant must apply for a rehabilitation evaluation before seeking an award from the deputy.
Note: When a claimant demonstrates that he did not recover the full value of the damages he sustained under the statute, the employer is only entitled to recover a pro rata share of compensation paid or to be paid.
Note: Justifiable reluctance by employer to accept claim is not grounds for award of attorney's fees under Section 440.34. A claim must contain sufficient information to act as notice to an employer.
Note: In regards to determining an attorney's fee award, the Deputy is not relieved from considering the statutory standards.
Note: Deputy Commissioner is without authority to require employer/carrier to withhold money due the claimant and to periodically pay claimant's attorney.
Note: Ordinary household services are considered gratuitous, and cannot form the basis of an award for attendant care services.
Note: When a carrier acts in bad faith, that employer/carrier is responsible for payment of claimant's attorney's fees.
Note: A claimant's bare complaints of continued pain so that the claimant feels unable to work is not the sort of injury that is so observable, so medical expertise is required to establish injury.
Note: Injured worker shall be entitled to reasonable attorney's fees from the carrier where the carrier or employer denies a compensable injury occurred, and injured worker prevails on the issue of compensability.
Note: Unless there is a clear abuse of discretion, or a departure from the law, the decisions of the deputy commissioner in regards to the bad faith of the carrier will be upheld.
Note: Claimant's application for hearing for the sole purpose of obtaining deputy commissioner's approval of contract to employ attorney, should not be construed as a claim, as it does not meet the claim requirements under ยง 440.19.
Note: Failing to work because of termination of employment does not meet requirements to receive TTD benefits, which are reserved for instances where the employee is unable to work due to injury; an attorney who presents a motion for attorney's fees should state the grounds for the motion.
Note: Even if compensabilty is subsequently admitted, a claimant shall be entitled to a reasonable attorney's fee where a carrier or employer denies that an injury occurred for which compensation benefits are payable, and the claimant prevails on the issue of compensability.
Note: That the deputy failed to use the magic words "based on the A.M.A. Guides " in finding a permanent physical impairment of the claimant therefore provides no grounds for relief.
Note: When an employer/carrier admits a compensable injury, there is no basis for assessing attorney's fees.
Note: The absence of an express authorizing provision does not preclude deputy approval of an attorney fee arrangement.
Note: Permanent impairment can be proved by qualified expert testimony based on the training, experience, and expertise of the witness or on other accepted medical guides or schedules prepared by specialist groups or associations.
Note: Statutes changing liability of employer/carrier from what it was when injury occured, may not be applied retroactively.
Note: If it is reasonably possible to identify items or expenses of independent personal benefit, then the deputy must do so and include the value of such personal benefit as part of the average weekly wage.
Note: Where there is no medical evidence that a claimant is unable to work, he must seek work within his physical capabilities.
Note: JCC abused discretion in lowering the attorney's fees to below the presumptive rate.
Note: JCC cannot revise attorney billing without substantiating evidence.
Note: Dismissal with prejudice was inappropriate. Claimant is not responsible for IME excess cost.
Note: If after mediation the carrier accepts the claim, it operates as a successful prosecution for purposes of an award of attorney's fees.
Note: Claimant can recover attorney's fees when filing for medical benefits only.
Note: Attorney mishandled client's property and did not follow proper procedure in charging fees in workers comp case.
Note: Attorney fees appropriate for pre-petition time if petition not dismissed.
Note: No award of attorney's fees where attorney asked for medical benefits only.
Note: No entitlement to prejudgment interest on an attorney fee award in a workers' compensation proceeding until the amount of the fee has been approved.
Note: The determinative factor in placing liability under Section 440.42(3) is whether the second compensable accident causes injury which is independent from or an exacerbation of the first compensable accident.
Note: E/C are exempt from liability for attorney's fees for services rendered in connection with the informal dispute resolution process, unless expressly authorized.
Note: Absent circumstances beyond the E/C's control, they cannot prevent a 20% penalty for being late on an installment payment simply by filing a notice of denial.
Note: For an E/C to be liable to the claimant's attorney for fees in securing PTD benefits, there needs to be competent substantial evidence that the claimant received more than she had already been receiving from the E/C.
Note: Unless there is competent substantial evidence that the attorney secured benefits for the claimant, he/she is not entitled to attorney's fees.
Note: Claimant shall be responsible for the payment of his/her own attorney's fees in connection with a settlement, pursuant to Fl. statute.
Note: Claimant must be responsible for his own attorney's fees in connection with a settlement.
Note: If there are specific findings of fact that the E/C proceeded in bad faith, attorney's fees may be awarded.
Note: Prejudgment interest on costs in eminent domain cases is awardable only if there is an appropriate basis for awarding that interest
Note: Where a claimant has brought suit to be able to see an IME and the E/C gives in at the last minute, the claimant is not precluded from an award of attorney's fees.
Note: If claimants covered by the old 21-day rule governing entitlement to attorney's fees in workers' compensation cases wish to invoke their right to attorney's fees under that provision when they file a "Request for Assistance" with the EAOO, they must file something in addition to the "Request for Assistance" which places the E/C on actual noticeof an obligation to make a decision regarding the acceptance of a claim within 21 days.
Note: There is no entitlement to interest on attorney fees in a workers' compensation case until the amount of the fee has been approved by the JCC.
Note: Tips can only be used in calculating AWW if they are reported for federal income tax purposes.
Note: Attorney's fees may only be rewarded when the claimant prevails on a petition for benefits containing a claim for medical benefits only.
Note: Under certain circumstances, costs an expert reasonably incurs in preparing testimony may be taxed, even though the testimony proves unnecessary.
Note: Once a party's liability for fees is established, such date fixes the time for awarding prejudgment interest on fees, notwithstanding that the actual amount of same has not yet been determined.
Note: Lay testimony can prove dispositive on entitlement to medical benefits, in an appropriate case.
Note: JCC's determination that attorney's fees are to be awarded should include an analysis and a breakdown of the numbers.
Note: "Other health providers" are "physicians or any recognized practitioner who provides skilled services pursuant to a prescription or under the supervision or direction of a physician", and that includes licensed psychologists.
Note: Where the present value of the increase in attendant care benefits payable to family members, remand is necessary.
Note: To the extent a collective bargaining agreement's intent to displace the jurisdiction of judges of compensation claims entirely falls short in some particular, the result may be an alternative dispute resolution system that supplements, modifies or replaces only a portion of the provisions of chapter 440 that would otherwise be applicable.
Note: No authority authorizing a claimant to file a separate or independent claim for attorney's fees against an employer.
Note: It is madea misdemeanor for anyone to receive a fee in a workers' compensation case for services rendered unless the judge of compensation claims has approved the fee.
Note: When awarding payment of a surgery, the JCC shall also establish an entitlement to an award of taxable costs.
Note: The 21 day rule cannot be invoked until a the hearing has taken place and the evidence has been presented.
Note: An E/C can prevent the tolling of interest on an award of attorney's fees by making an unconditional tender of the full amount upon judgment or placing the funds in the court's registry.
Note: Where the date of injury is stated incorrectly but the employer was sufficiently aware of the actual date of injury, that may not be used to avoid paying attorneys fees.
Note: An award of attorney's fees to a workers' compensation claimant is part of a covered claim for which FIGA may be responsible.
Note: In awarding attorney's fees, the statutory guidelines are not to be departed from except under extraordinary circumstances.
Note: Where a claimant did not earn enough money to file a tax return, he/she is still required to submit a report of his/her tips to the employer and failure to do so will result in the tips not being used for AWW calculations.
Note: The claimant may obtain an independent medical examination of his own choice without being obligated for the cost of the examination unless the injury occurred before the enactment of 440.13(5).
Note: To establish entitlement to PTD benefits, a claimant must show either that he is unable to do light work uninterruptedly due to physical limitations, or that he has conducted a lengthy exhaustive job search which has proved futile.
Note: Within 14 days after receipt of a petition for benefits by certified mail, the carrier must either pay the requested benefits without prejudice to its right to deny within 120 days from receipt of the petition or file a notice of denial with the Division.
Note: The legislative repeal of the 21-day rule set forth in section 440.34(3)(b) is substantive and so in a case involving a 1990 accident the statute as it existed at the time shall be applied to the claim for attorney's fees.
Note: Attorney time sheets must be legible and provide dates, times, and nature of services.
Note: Attendant care is a periodic benefit so as to be subject to a new claim for each respective period when the benefit becomes due.
Note: A claimant may recover attorney's fees when the E/C fails or refuses to pay a claim within 21 days.
Note: Before a health care provider may provide medical services under the act, it must be informed by the employer or its carrier of authorization to provide such services.
Note: In order to preserve issues for appeal they must be raised in the case-in-chief.
Note: The 21 day period the E/C has to pay benefits begins from the date there was actual notice of a claim, not the date the acknowledged notice was received.
Note: The fact that the claimant was forced to retain an attorney is not enough to show economic loss.
Note: If there is CSE to justify a departure from the fee schedule, the order will not be disturbed.
Note: A claimant with a permanent impairment rating has some 'physical limitation,' and can establish his wage loss claim by demonstrating a causal connection between the physical limitation and his earnings.
Note: An attorney's fee should not be based on time and labor expended on unrelated claims, or in connection with benefits which are voluntarily provided without the necessity of the attorney's intervention.
Note: To the extent that the amount of the recovery of benefits is used as a factor in determining a reasonable fee to be paid in lump sum, the amount of the recovery should be deemed to be a sum equal to the present value thereof.
Note: Attorney's fees are appropriate where an attorney has secured benefits for the claimant, whether monetary or otherwise.
Note: Attorney's fees will be awarded for the securing of medical benefits only when at the time of the filing of the claim the claimant was not entitled to wage-loss benefits from the same accident.
Note: If the employer fails to provide treatment, care, and attendance after request by the injured employee, the employee may do so at the expense of the employer, the reasonableness and the necessity to be approved by a deputy commissioner.
Note: An award of attorney's fees must be based upon the benefits secured and the time reasonably spent in obtaining them.
Note: Because the payment of wage-loss benefits is contingent upon future events, the value of an unexpired term of wage-loss benefits cannot be ascertained, and cannot be used as a vehicle for reduction of an attorney's fee award.
Note: Claimants can recover attorney's fees in cases in which the deputy commissioner issues an order finding that the carrier has acted in bad faith with regard to handling an injured worker's claim and the injured worker has suffered economic loss.
Note: A bad faith claim may be predicated upon a delay in payment which is occasioned by a reckless failure to ascertain the claimant's rights.
Note: Proving the amount of a fee cannot be included in an attorney's fee award.
Note: Attorney's fees are to be standardized, absent extreme circumstances.
Note: Once an employer or carrier has denied compensability of an injury and failed to make timely payment of benefits, the employer and carrier may be held liable for attorney's fees.
Note: A claimant shall be responsible for the payment of his own attorney's fees, except that a claimant shall be entitled to recover a reasonable attorney's fee from a carrier or employer in cases in which the deputy commissioner issues an order finding that a carrier has acted in bad faith with regard to handling an injured worker's claim and the injured worker has suffered economic loss.
Note: Generally, an order directing payment of medical bills is improper unless the medical bills are placed in evidence or there is clear and unequivocal testimony as to the amount of bills.
Note: Appellate attorney's fees are largely subject to JCC discretion.
Note: With regard to the award of bad faith attorney's fees, a claimant is entitled to recover such fees in cases in which the JCC issues an order finding that a carrier has acted in bad faith with regard to handling an injured worker's claim and the injured worker suffered an economic loss.
Note: A claimant is entitled to recover a reasonable attorney's fee from the E/C if the E/C denies that a compensable injury occurred and the claimant prevails on the issue of compensability.
Note: Benefits, if timely and voluntarily paid by the E/C, are not subject to attorney's fees.
Note: FL Stat (2002) 440.34 does not apply retroactively.
Note: Claimant was entitled to more future attendant services than the JCC gave her.
Note: The probative value and weight to be given to an expert witness is a question for the trier of fact.
Note: When quantifying future attendant care benefits for fee determination purposes, inflationary factors should be considered only when future costs are uncertain.
Note: Even when there is bad faith involved, attorney's fees cannot be excessive.
Note: An attorney in a workers' compensation case is entitled to recover fees for the effort involved in prosecuting a claim for attorney's fees.
Note: In any case where injury and MMI/PTD fall in the same calendar year, the amount of the supplement will equal zero until January 1 of the year following MMI/PTD.
Note: Where the attorney's fee guideline seems to not have been followed, the order was reversed and remanded.
Note: An order finding them liable for a portion of claimant's attorney's fees was reversed.
Note: Attorney fee award where jurisdiction reserved as to amount not ripe for appeal.
Note: If an injured employee was working during substantially the whole of 13 weeks before the accident, then his average weekly wage should be determined to be one-thirteenth of the total amount of wages earned in the employment during the 13 weeks.
Note: Failure to advise a claimant of a job-search requirement excuses non-compliance with that requirement.
Note: In awarding a reasonable attorney's fee, the deputy commissioner may only consider those benefits to the claimant that the attorney is responsible for securing.
Note: Bad faith includes a carrier's conduct in the handling of a claim which amounts to "fraud; malice; oppression; or willful, wanton, or reckless disregard of the rights of the claimant." Either active or passive delay or denial of benefits are subject to the provisions of the statute, in light of the theory that the workers' compensation laws should be self-executing and that benefits should be paid without the necessity of legal or administrative hearings.
Note: CSE to support the DC's finding of a compensable injury under an exposure theory.
Note: The fact that a claimant has counsel cannot be relied on excuse the E/C from the basic nonadversarial duties to monitor the claim and inform the claimant of his rights and obligations.
Note: A temporally separate hearing on the issue of bad faith is not necessary.
Note: Minimizing an attorney's fee because the E/C's resistance to the claim was minimal is improper.
Note: Departure from fee should be ordered when presumptive fee produced by statutory formula is manifestly unfair.
Note: Amendments to 440.34(3)(b) that allow employer 30 day grace period cannot be applied retroactively.
Note: Compelling disclosure of attorney's billing information does not depart from the essential requirements of law.
Note: Attorney entitled to fees for obtaining re-authorization of treating physician.
Note: Claimant not entitled to award of attorney's fees for non-appellate time expended in securing IME.
Note: Claimant entitled to costs related to mail expenses, postage, and photocopying charges.
Note: Order deemed final and appealable where JCC fails to enter ruling on fully tried issue.
Note: Award of attorney's fees must be based on evidence in the record.
Note: Attorney entitled to fees for work in connection with relevant criminal matter.
Note: JCC can only approve a fee as reasonable if it equals statutorily established percentage of value of benefits secured on behalf of claimant.
Note: Trial judge can award attorney's fees in workers' compensation case in a rule nisi proceeding.
Note: Certification of question whether section 440.34(1) clearly and unambiguously establish percentage forumla as sole standard for attorney's fee.
Note: Medical expert witness fees for testimony as to the value of the medical treatment recommended are not taxable against the E/C.
Note: Attorney fee provision in section 440.34(1) does not violate the separation of powers doctrine, the due process clause, the equal protection clause, the right to counsel, or the right to freely contract as provided by the Florida Constitution.
Note: In the motion for fees, the unsuccessful claimant has not demonstrated (or even alleged) how this appeal satisfies the 'heavy burden' under Wick Roofing to justify the discretionary allowance of appellate attorney's fees.
Note: The employee's counsel could, and should, have requested a continuance to alleviate any problems of surprise, but failed to do so.
Note: Section 440.34(1) clearly and unambiguously established the percentage fee formula provided as the sole standard for calculating attorney's fees.
Note: Claimant's award of $20,500 in attorney's fees far exceeded the statutorily mandated percentage of the benefits awarded, and was reversed.
Note: The judge of compensation claims miscalculated the total amount of fees paid by the City of Tampa, based on the application of the formula provided in section 440.34(1), Florida Statutes (2003).
Note: When a claimant is entitled to recover attorney fees from a carrier or employer as provided by section 440.34(3)(a), (b), (c), or (d), the claimant is entitled to recover a reasonable attorney's fee. Reasonable attorney fees for claimants, when not otherwise defined in the workers' compensation statute, are to be determined using the factors of rule 4-1.5(b) of the Rules Regulating the Florida Bar.
Note: Paralegal costs fall within the sphere of attorney fees for lump-sum settlements.
Note: Attorney's fees agreed to by claimant and his lawyer were unreasonable because the lawyer had already been compensated for the benefits secured.
Note: An employer's agreement to provide medical treatment is enforceable through rule nisi even if the underlying claim remains open.
| 